Dor Deah misrepresents Chabad & Noahide Law?

RELATED ARTICLE:  Can non-Jews have eternal life?



To start off, distinctions have to be made between fact and opinion:

It’s a FACT that the Tanya teaches that the soul of a non-Jew stems from the Sitra Achra (an ungodly source) and is intrinsically impure.


While it is true that Chabad holds of the opinion that if a non-Jew becomes a Jew (to their likings), it means he has always had a Jewish soul and is the reincarnation of a born Jew who is returning to the fold, it is also true that this is only true for converts that Chabad themselves accept, not just anyone who converts.  (We all know that Chabad rarely performs conversions for this very reason.)


What many fail to notice is that Chabad completely strips away any acknowledgment of the individual consciously choosing (as the Torah puts it) “Life over Death” and “ Blessing over Curse”.  In other words, when we regulate ethics to merely the reflexes of a superior bloodline, or in this case a Jewish neshama (soul), we demoralize the message of Torah.  The Torah’s message is a message that can only be appreciated by someone who has himself struggled with the inclination that leads to evil.  This must first be stated to make the moral distinction between our view of converts and Chabad’s view.


It is true that Chaz”al held that the Hasidei umot Ha’olam (the pious of the nations) would acquire a share in the world to come.  It is also true among Chaz”al were those who held that they wouldn’t. Chaz”al were split on the issue.  The view that they would have a place in the world to come is the view expressed in the MT only because the Rambam sided with this opinion, though when it comes to practical halakha, it he contradicts.  Unlike the non-legal opinion given in Hil. Melakhim 8 that the pious of the nations have a place in the world to come which has no bearing on our actions, in the laws dealing with conversion, the Rambam brings the following opinion as being something that we are oblgiated to inform the potential convert of.  In Hil. Issurei Bi’a 14,4 we find:


[…] he is to be told, “Do you know that the world to come is hidden away only for the righteous, and they are Israel.”


Is it of no significance that neither the Talmud, the Rambam, nor the Shulhan ‘Arukh state that when a potential convert comes, we must inform him that he can be assured eternal life even if he simply keeps the Laws of Noah alone?  But to the contrary we are given a halakha that when faced with a potential convert, we are to tell him that the world to come is hidden away for Israel alone.


What are we essentially pointing out here?

We are emphasizing that the question of whether a non-Jew who piously keeps the Laws of Noah is assured a place in the world to come is not a question the Beit Din haGadol (Great Sanhedrin) voted on.  The Beit Din haGadol only voted in areas of practical halacha, on questions concerning how exactly one DOES the commandments.  They did not vote on metaphysical issues like whether someone would or would not have share in the world to come.  These are areas truth they can not affect, nor areas which HaShem commanded us to believe them concerning.  The Torah commandment is “you shall DO according to all they instruct you.”  And by the simple fact that Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai could not agree on this issue would rule out the possibility that one could say that it was a clarification given on Har Sinai.  So like I said in my video, neither we nor Chaz”al are not 100% certain that righteous non-Jews can acquire a share in the world to come merely by keeping the Seven Laws of Noah.


NOTE:  I never never stated that I believe that righteous non-Jews would not be allotted a portion in the world to come.  I have simply pointed out that it is a matter of dispute among Chaz”al and that the only thing we are 100% sure of is that (the righteous of) Israel have the world to come put aside especially for them.  This alone is enough reason why it would be better for a non-Jew to become a full Torah keeping Jew than remain a non Jew, on the obvious condition that he accepts Torah and commits to upholding it.


Everything I have said thus far is easily verifiable in the Tanya, MT, Kesef Mishna and Lechem Mishna.



Any moral individual should have no problem distinguishing a group that believes that a person’s ultimate value is intrinsic to hisself (ie: blood, ‘Jewish soul,’ pedigree, etc.) from a group that believes that someone is in 100% in control and responsible for how valuable they could become by deciding to chose a life of Torah, a life committed to upholding G-d’s righteous commands.





R’ Asher Meza


See further:  Can non-Jews have eternal life?




Post navigation

  1. Montetraps

    [url=]injections for ed[/url]

  2. Ivyshade

    [url=]prazosin price[/url]

  3. Ivyshade

    [url=]lasix 20 mg price in india[/url]

  4. Lisashade

    [url=]metformin pill for sale[/url]

  5. Maryshade

    [url=]zanaflex 4mg price in usa[/url]

  6. Williamboato

    ivermectin shampoo ivermectin iv ivermectin 1% cream generic

  7. Sueshade

    [url=]prednisolone buy[/url]

  8. Williamboato

    ivermectin horse paste ivermectin 8 mg how ivermectin works

  9. Miashade

    [url=]generic sildenafil without a prescription[/url]

  10. Williamboato

    ivermectin pills for scabies where to buy ivermectin near me stromectol over the counter

  11. Williamboato

    prednisone rx coupon buy prednisone mexico prednisone tablets india

  12. Williamboato

    prednisone online india prednisone 60 mg price prednisone over the counter australia

  13. Ivyshade

    [url=]viagra soft online[/url]

  14. Williamboato

    cialis paypal pay with how long cialis last cialis for sale

  15. Williamboato

    the best ed pills cheap drugs online ed for men

  16. [url=]cialis 80mg online[/url]

  17. CharlesMaimi

    buy ivermectin for humans online ivermectin for scabies dosage is ivermax the same as ivermectin

  18. [url=]purchase tadalafil online[/url]

  19. CharlesMaimi

    pills erectile dysfunction non prescription ed pills non prescription ed drugs

  20. [url=]rx tadalafil[/url]

  21. Paulshade

    [url=]cialis online fast delivery[/url]

  22. CharlesMaimi

    prescription drugs online prescription drugs without prior prescription canadian drugs online

  23. CharlesMaimi

    prescription drugs prescription drugs without prior prescription amoxicillin without a doctor’s prescription

  24. Janeshade


  25. [url=]seroquel ocd[/url]

  26. Janeshade

    [url=]cheapest finasteride generic[/url]

  27. CharlesMaimi

    best ed treatment ed drugs compared best erection pills

  28. [url=]canadian pharmacy coupon[/url]

  29. CharlesMaimi

    generic propecia prescription generic propecia for cheap without precscription merck propecia

  30. CharlesMaimi

    propecia 5mga how do i get propecia propecia hair

  31. Canadaskymn

    india pharmacy mail order buy prescriptions from india pharmacy generic drugs india order online

  32. [url=]best india pharmacy[/url]

  33. Canadaskymn

    pharmacy without dr prescriptions canadian pharmacies not requiring prescription trusted online canadian pharmacy reviews

  34. cost modafinil 100mg modafinil 200mg canada

  35. [url=]where can i buy prednisolone in the uk[/url]

  36. [url=]disulfiram 200 mg[/url]

  37. Canadaskymn

    trusted online canadian pharmacy reviews trusted online canadian pharmacy reviews canadian pharmacy certified canada pharmacy online

  38. order generic provigil modafinil order buy provigil 100mg online cheap

  39. is erythromycin safe during pregnancy

  40. [url=]retin a medication[/url]

  41. modafinil 100mg over the counter cost modafinil 100mg

  42. provigil generic order provigil without prescription modafinil uk

  43. modafinil 200mg oral cost provigil 100mg

  44. buy provigil pills brand provigil 100mg

  45. MichaelVof

    clomid for sale canada buy clomid 50mg clomid tablets

  46. MichaelVof

    viagra viagra sildenafil 20 mg

  47. Lisashade

    [url=]prednisolone 5mg price uk[/url]

  48. [url=]retino 0.025 gel[/url]

  49. provigil 100mg pill modafinil tablet

  50. order modafinil 200mg provigil 200mg sale

  51. MichaelVof

    clomid for sale clomid tablets buy clomid

  52. modafinil 200mg sale generic provigil

  53. modafinil over the counter provigil 100mg oral

  54. MichaelVof

    viagra tablets for men sildenafil 20 mg viagra

  55. MichaelVof

    stromectol price usa stromectol price usa ivermectin without a doctor prescription

  56. MichaelVof

    sildenafil citrate 100mg for sale viagra viagra pills

  57. provigil 100mg uk modafinil 100mg us

  58. Paulshade

    [url=]cheap canadian pharmacy[/url]

  59. purchase provigil online modafinil 100mg usa buy modafinil 200mg for sale

  60. buy provigil online cheap order modafinil sale

  61. [url=]buy oral ivermectin[/url]

  62. stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol for humans for sale stromectol 12 mg tablets

  63. erythromycin benzoyl peroxide topical gel

  64. can you buy stromectol over the counter stromectol for sale stromectol 12 mg tablets

  65. stromectol 12 mg tablets scabies ivermectin dosage stromectol for sale

  66. Lisashade

    [url=]buy zestril online[/url]

  67. when will viagra be generic pfizer viagra 100mg price buy viagra online canada

  68. Maryshade

    [url=]where can i buy 1 viagra pill[/url]

  69. [url=]fildena 150 online[/url]

  70. Janeshade

    [url=]tretinoin 1 cream online[/url]

  71. [url=]anafranil drug prices[/url]

  72. viagra discount sildenafil 100 mg where can i buy viagra over the counter

  73. viagra cost per pill viagra viagra over the counter

  74. is erythromycin a penicillin

  75. Andrewfet

    buying cialis with dapoxetine best price for daily cialis cheap generic cialis hvtsgeahdSlariBtjAbotsq

  76. Andrewfet

    cialis black reviews tadalafil 20mg cialis drug interactions

  77. Andrewfet

    free samples of cialis canadian pharmacy ezzz cialis generic cialis professional

  78. Andrewfet

    cialish price of cialis 20 mg typical cialis prescription strength

  79. Andrewfet

    cialis lilly brand generic version of cialis inexpensive real cialis

  80. erythromycin ointment eye

  81. Andrewfet

    generic cialis buy best price for daily cialis europe cialis

  82. zoracrose

    [url=]Cialis[/url] Oonhna Other measures may be appropriate such as continuous ECG blood pressure and pulse oximetry monitoring administering intravenous crystalloids if the patient is hypotensive and administering oxygen. Qsottl Viagra Cialis Assuefazione buy cialis 5mg – cialis 40 mg Ysrthk Low blood sugar is called hypoglycemia.

  83. side effects of erythromycin

  84. RalphEdirl

    cialis overdose price of cialis 20 mg

  85. StromTWirm

    [url=]ivermectin brand name[/url] ivermectin oral solution

  86. ivermectin 3mg pill ivermectin iv

  87. Chesterswogy ivermectin 50 mg

  88. erythromycin allergy

  89. erythromycin ophthalmic ointment

  90. CameronFeedy

    prescription drugs online without doctor without doctor prescription

  91. StevenRon best canadian pharmacy online

  92. ThomasDog

    [url=]online prescription for ed meds[/url] canadian pharmacy

  93. RalphEdirl

    chinese cialis buy tadalafil

  94. CameronFeedy

    cvs prescription prices without insurance mexican pharmacy without prescription

  95. ThomasDog

    [url=]online prescription for ed meds[/url] non prescription ed drugs

  96. CameronFeedy

    ed prescription drugs canadian drug

  97. plaquenil prescribing information hydroxychloroquine pills for sale purchase hydroxychloroquine online

  98. MichaelTeelm where to buy viagra

  99. MichaelFem

    [url=]viagra[/url] order viagra online

  100. Jamisontog

    buy viagra online canada viagra pills viagra cost per pill
    [url=]viagra shop[/url] viagra amazon

  101. BrandonLaf

    buy viagra online canada online doctor prescription for viagra

  102. donate for ukraine

    Hi there, of course this paragraph is in fact nice and I have learned lot of
    things from it on the topic of blogging. thanks. donate for ukraine


    hiya everyone, I was just checkin out this blog and I really like the foundation of the article, and have nothing to do, so if anyone would like to to have an enjoyable convo about it, please contact me on yahoo, my name is jessica meautle

  104. MichaelTeelm buy generic 100mg viagra online

  105. canada pharmacy online reviews

    pharmacy drug store

  106. MichaelFem

    [url=]sildenafil 20 mg[/url] viagra cost per pill

  107. BrandonLaf

    buy viagra online usa viagra cost

  108. Jamisontog

    best place to buy viagra online viagra shop best place to buy generic viagra online
    [url=]sildenafil[/url] viagra online usa

  109. MichaelFem

    [url=]viagra pills[/url] viagra online usa

  110. MichaelTeelm cheap viagra online

  111. Jamisontog

    viagra discount sildenafil 20 mg buy real viagra online
    [url=]sildenafil[/url] п»їviagra pills

  112. BrandonLaf

    order viagra online viagra shop

  113. SildeTeelm over the counter viagra

  114. MichaelFem

    [url=]sildenafil[/url] over the counter viagra

  115. buying amoxicillin in mexico amoxicillin 500mg

  116. Stepheneralo

    [url=]clomid price in usa[/url] purchase clomid online uk

  117. Georgeram

    generic zithromax azithromycin buy zithromax 500mg online

  118. RaymondOnepe

    prednisone pills 10 mg prednisone 20mg tab price

  119. RickySpupt

    [url=]zithromax 1000 mg online[/url] where can i get zithromax

  120. Georgeram

    order prednisone 10 mg tablet prednisone uk price

  121. Stepheneralo prednisone 5 50mg tablet price

  122. Robertzet

    buy prednisone online fast shipping purchase prednisone canada

  123. Georgeram

    doxycycline 40 mg generic coupon doxycycline brand

  124. ShelbyLeW

    [url=]where to buy clomid in canada[/url] genuine clomid online

  125. PhilipGow

    metformin 500 mg without prescription metformin online purchase lasix
    [url=]tadalafil – generic[/url] tadalafil online without prescription

  126. order plaquenil pills purchase plaquenil online plaquenil hydroxychloroquine 200mg tablets

  127. RickySpupt

    atorvastatin lipitor buy lipitor online usa lasix 40mg
    [url=]lasix tablet[/url] lasix 100 mg

  128. RaymondOnepe п»їlipitor price comparison

  129. PhilipGow

    lasix furosemide 40 mg lasix medication lasix furosemide
    [url=]lasix 100 mg[/url] lasix 40 mg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.