Interpreting Gen 49:10

I want to quickly analyze a pasuk in Parashat Vayechi perek mem tet : pasuk yud

or Gen 49:10.

And why do I want to analyze this pasuk or why is this pasuk any more relevant to us than any pasuk in Torah?

Well friends, the answer is because no other verse has been used to justify more new movements or offshoots from Judaism than this one, and after this is it would be the pasuk in Parashat Yitro or Deut 18 of:

נָבִיא מִקִּרְבְּךָ מֵאַחֶיךָ כָּמֹנִי


And friends the reason this pasuk in Parashat Vayechi has been so heavily tampered with is mainly because of the four words עַד כִּי-יָבֹא שִׁילֹה that can and have been translated ambiguously throughout te centuries.

At least the last portion of that statement.


However the problem is not that Jews never understood the plain meaning of the pasuk but rather its because it mention Scepter and Yehudah, two notions that later in Jewish history became synonymous with redemption and the figure who has come to be known as the Messiah.


This is why commentators even bother to expound this pasuk in the first place and by expounding created fervor.


One must realize that mysterious or eschatological interpretations for this pasuk did not begin with Islam or Christianity, two groups that because of Jewish messianic expectation regarding this pasuk have adopted this pasuk to endorse the arrival of either Jesus or Mohammed but that many many rabbis throughout the ages held this verse as eschatological as well, even Onkelos.

Now many also did not… I should make that clear.



The problem is like with almost any commentary to Torah, that the commentators begin with an assumption or expectation and then use the text before them to accommodate those expectations.


In other words claiming that their understanding of a concept predates even its source.


Whether it’s claiming that the patriarchs keep full halacha before it was even developed or claiming that pesukim are there to justify what has not been created yet and all the while claiming that all this in someway would of been known even to the hebrews back then.

In other words that the Hebrews back then would of known and agreed with everything the meforshim wrote after them even when the meforshim (the commentators) even contradicted themselves countless times..


And friends one thing you must remember when understanding Torah is that “Peshat is King” in other words the literal meaning of the text is the only thing the text is trying to relate to us as the gemara states in Masehect Peshachim of

“Ein Mikra Yotzei m’Ydei Peshuto” That a verse does not depart from its literal meaning..


And if you are wondering about this new method of biblical interpretation known as “Pardes” know that this was also invented post the 13th century by kabbalist in order to insert later kabbalistic ideas into Torah.

Now the concept of Pardes the story with Acher does appear in the Talmud but not having anything to do with mystical levels of the Torah interpretation known as Peshat Remez Drash and Sod….(PRDS)


But anyways the pasuk reads

לֹא-יָסוּר שֵׁבֶט מִיהוּדָה, וּמְחֹקֵק מִבֵּין רַגְלָיו, עַד כִּי-יָבֹא שִׁילֹה, וְלוֹ יִקְּהַת עַמִּים.

(Contextually:Jacob is blessings his sons)

לֹא-יָסוּר שֵׁבֶט מִיהוּדָה The scepter shall not depart from Judah וּמְחֹקֵק מִבֵּין רַגְלָיו nor the ruler’s staff from between his feet,  עַד כִּי-יָבֹא שִׁילֹה until tribute (From Shai, shilo) shall come to him

וְלוֹ יִקְּהַת עַמִּים and the homage (from Yikaha) of the people (amim) shall be his. (or shall be paid to him).

Saying that Judah will be the ruler till he becomes the full king and his kingship will last for ever,

Basically saying, That Judah will be the tribe from whom kings and rulers will be drawn from.


This my friends this is the Peshat and there is no running from this, and how do we know that this was the only understanding of this pasuk before the destruction of the 2nd temple well mainly because what other source did Jews ever have to claim that kingship was regulated to the tribe of Judah.


Remember everything Israel did during and after the closing of the Torah had to stem from Torah and as you know there is no other pasuk any where in Torah they could of got it from.


And not only the King but the Nasi the head of the Sanhedrin was always limited to having someone from the tribe of Judah to even the Exilarch.


Now being that the pasuk references Judah ruling one would say that doesnt this in itself tell us its messianic?

Well if you mean messianic because kings were mashach (they were anointed) with oil then yes but referring to some future redeemer that we should await daily than no…


Post navigation

  1. Montetraps

    [url=]impotence pills[/url]

  2. order viagra online cheap – buy viagra 100mg for sale sildenafil 50mg pills for men

  3. Jamesappex

    free samples for cialis cialis usa cialis super active 20mg

  4. Jamesappex

    erectional dysfunction buying pills online medications list

  5. Jamesappex

    best pill for ed erection pills cheap drugs

  6. Jamesappex

    muse ed drug erectile dysfunction pills ed drug prices

  7. order prednisolone 40mg without prescription – gabapentin 800mg generic purchase tadalafil online cheap

  8. Jamesappex

    erectile dysfunction medicines ed drugs over the counter drug prices comparison

  9. Jamesappex

    prednisone 10 mg price prednisone 60 mg daily ordering prednisone

  10. Jamesappex

    where can i buy prednisone online without a prescription buy prednisone prednisone 7.5 mg

  11. order augmentin 1000mg online cheap – augmentin 375mg over the counter order generic cialis 20mg

  12. GregoryOrada

    propecia sale propecia prices cost of finasteride

  13. GregoryOrada

    finasteride 5mg finasteride 1 mg propecia where to buy

  14. sulfamethoxazole usa – viagra 150mg drug viagra 150mg pill

  15. GregoryOrada

    ivermectin for mange in foxes ivermectin dosage for cats ear mites ivermectin cost canada

  16. GregoryOrada

    medication for ed best ed pills at gnc erectile dysfunction medicines

  17. GregoryOrada

    legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription comfortis for dogs without vet prescription legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription

  18. cephalexin 250mg pill – order erythromycin online buy erythromycin 250mg sale

  19. GregoryOrada

    how can i order prescription drugs without a doctor prescription drugs how to get prescription drugs without doctor

  20. GregoryOrada

    buy propecia tablets buy cheap propecia cheap propecia pills

  21. stromectol for humans for sale stromectol 3 mg tablets price stromectol for humans for sale

  22. fildena 100mg over the counter – stromectol online pharmacy ivermectin 6 tablet

  23. india pharmacy mail order generic drugs without doctor’s prescription generic drugs without doctor’s prescription

  24. aarp approved canadian online pharmacies highest rated canadian pharmacies pharmacy without dr prescriptions

  25. erythromycin abbreviation

  26. provigil buy online order modafinil 200mg without prescription provigil 100mg canada

  27. order modafinil 200mg sale modafinil for sale buy generic provigil 100mg

  28. buy provigil online purchase modafinil

  29. meds online without doctor prescription legitimate online pharmacies india generic drugs without doctor’s prescription

  30. order budesonide – buy rhinocort generic buy disulfiram 250mg pill

  31. order modafinil 100mg online cheap provigil usa

  32. order generic modafinil 100mg order modafinil 200mg online cheap order modafinil generic

  33. Douglasrow

    clomid tablets for sale clomid for sale canada clomid

  34. order provigil pills modafinil 100mg canada

  35. Douglasrow

    tadalafil 10mg price buy tadalafil online buy tadalafil online

  36. buy cefuroxime without prescription – brand methocarbamol buy generic cialis 5mg

  37. generic modafinil brand modafinil

  38. buy modafinil generic provigil usa provigil 100mg ca

  39. Douglasrow

    stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol 3 mg tablets price prescribing stromectol

  40. order modafinil online cheap modafinil 100mg pills purchase provigil pills

  41. Douglasrow

    best price for daily cialis cialis from india best price for daily cialis

  42. brand ampicillin 250mg – cipro online purchase tadalafil pill

  43. Douglasrow

    tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription best price for daily cialis tadalafil tablets 20 mg india

  44. provigil 200mg uk buy provigil 200mg

  45. modafinil 100mg usa provigil 200mg without prescription

  46. order modafinil 200mg generic purchase provigil sale provigil 200mg brand

  47. Douglasrow

    buy clomid 50mg online clomid for sale canada buy clomid 50mg

  48. modafinil 100mg sale cheap modafinil

  49. modafinil 100mg pills provigil tablet

  50. EugeneDub

    stromectol for sale stromectol tablets for humans stromectol 12 mg tablets

  51. order amoxil generic – order zithromax 250mg online cheap order vardenafil for sale

  52. EugeneDub

    ivermectin cream for dogs stromectol tablets for humans ivermectin for tapeworms in cats

  53. EugeneDub

    stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol for humans for sale stromectol 12 mg tablets

  54. where can i buy ivermectin – stromectol pill cost levitra buy online

  55. Raymondgoock

    viagra online usa pfizer viagra 100mg price mexican viagra

  56. Raymondgoock

    when will viagra be generic pfizer viagra 100mg price where to buy viagra online

  57. doxycycline 200mg for sale – order cialis generic cialis 5mg for sale

  58. Raymondgoock

    viagra from canada sildenafil 100 mg where to buy viagra

  59. Robertacifs

    buy original cialis 10 mg buy tadalafil super active cialis with no prescription

  60. Robertacifs

    cialis purchase online canada generic tadalafil 20mg india 20mg cialis buy

  61. buy tadalafil 5mg generic – best canadian online pharmacy reviews purchase provigil online

  62. erythromycin cream for acne

  63. Robertacifs

    what does cialis look like cialis cialis 10mg generic

  64. Robertacifs

    cialis 20 mg tablets generic tadalafil 20mg india viagra/cialis black and gold 800

  65. erythromycin ophthalmic ointment usp 0.5

  66. order deltasone 5mg without prescription – isotretinoin online order isotretinoin 20mg generic

  67. Robertacifs

    overnight shipping of cialis tadalafil cialis canada paypal

  68. Robertacifs

    cialis pharmacy mastercard tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription which one is better viagra or cialis

  69. amoxil 1000mg pill – order zithromax 250mg sale viagra pills 50mg

  70. order prednisolone online – neurontin 100mg oral sildenafil 150mg tablet

  71. erythromycin ointment dosage erythromycin ointment for newborns

  72. RalphEdirl

    buying cialis in australia tadalafil

  73. purchase furosemide online – furosemide brand ivermectin 6mg pills for humans

  74. how to use erythromycin ophthalmic ointment erythromycin for fish tanks

  75. purchase plaquenil generic – oral baricitinib 2mg order baricitinib 2mg without prescription

  76. erythromycin antibiotic

  77. albuterol hfa
    albuterol sulfate inhalation
    ventolin inhaler coupons
    [url=]albuterol over the counter equivalent[/url]

  78. StromTWirm

    [url=]stromectol 3 mg tablets price[/url] ivermectin gel

  79. glucophage 500mg pills – norvasc 5mg cheap buy norvasc 10mg pill

  80. ivermectin for humans
    stromectol generic
    can you buy tablets for worms in humans
    [url=]stromectol for humans[/url]

  81. medication lasix 20 mg
    lasix side effects in elderly
    [url=]furosemide 20 mg tabs[/url]
    40 mg furosemide too much

  82. order lisinopril pill – cheap tenormin 100mg atenolol 50mg oral

  83. buy vardenafil 10mg pills – levitra 20mg uk buy clomid pills

  84. StevenRon legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription

  85. CameronFeedy

    carprofen without vet prescription prescription drugs online

  86. ThomasDog

    [url=]buy prescription drugs without doctor[/url] sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription

  87. albuterol cost – play slots order generic dapoxetine

  88. RalphEdirl

    cialis netherlands price of cialis 20 mg

  89. erythromycin cost erythromycin for sinus infection

  90. StevenRon prescription drugs canada buy online

  91. ThomasDog

    [url=]buy prescription drugs without doctor[/url] comfortis for dogs without vet prescription

  92. buy a viagra online buy priligy viagra

  93. buy synthroid generic – aristocort 4mg brand buy hydroxychloroquine 200mg online

  94. erythromycin gastroparesis

  95. cialis online canada – cost tadalafil viagra 50mg drug

  96. hydroxychloroquine canada order online how to get off plaquenil doctors prescribing hydroxychloroquine near me

  97. cheap viagra from canada pfizer discount coupons for viagra buy viagra from pfizer

  98. prednisone usa – buy amoxicillin 500mg generic buy amoxicillin online

  99. MichaelFem

    [url=]cost of viagra[/url] viagra online usa

  100. hydroxychloroquine pharmacy plaquenil for sale online generic hydroxychloroquine 200 mg

  101. diltiazem 180mg cost – generic diltiazem cost gabapentin 600mg

  102. Jamisontog

    buy viagra online usa online doctor prescription for viagra viagra online usa
    [url=]viagra shop[/url] when will viagra be generic

  103. MichaelTeelm buy generic 100mg viagra online

  104. BrandonLaf

    viagra discount cost of viagra

  105. buy furosemide 100mg pills – order doxycycline 100mg without prescription order doxycycline 200mg

  106. MichaelFem

    [url=]п»їviagra pills[/url] generic viagra walmart

  107. sildenafil tablet use viagra buy in tesco

  108. Jamisontog

    best place to buy generic viagra online sildenafil over the counter viagra
    [url=]sildenafil[/url] when will viagra be generic

  109. BrandonLaf

    viagra price how much is viagra

  110. where to get hydroxychloroquine otc

  111. order cenforce 50mg sale – buy rosuvastatin 20mg online domperidone buy online

  112. MichaelFem

    [url=]viagra[/url] when will viagra be generic

  113. BrandonLaf

    100mg viagra viagra pills

  114. albuterol from mexico ventolin

  115. Jamisontog

    buying viagra online sildenafil 20 mg п»їviagra pills
    [url=]viagra[/url] viagra 100mg price

  116. sildenafil 100mg drug – cialis 5mg cost order tadalafil 20mg sale

  117. BrandonLaf

    100mg viagra cost of viagra

  118. MichaelFem

    [url=]sildenafil[/url] viagra from india

  119. generic amoxicillin cost amoxicillin 500mg

  120. Georgeram

    where can you buy zithromax zithromax generic price

  121. Stepheneralo

    [url=]clomid medication uk[/url] where can i buy clomid over the counter

  122. RaymondOnepe

    clomid medication uk clomid cheap online

  123. order modafinil 200mg online – generic ed drugs budesonide without prescription

  124. Georgeram

    prednisone 10mg buy online prednisone 5 mg tablet cost

  125. save refuges

    It’s an awesome article in favor of all the web people; they will obtain advantage from it I am sure.
    save refuges

  126. plaquenil online purchase hydroxychloroquine plaquenil package insert

  127. Georgeram

    prednisone 500 mg tablet buying prednisone mexico

  128. Robertzet

    zithromax without prescription zithromax 500 without prescription

  129. Stepheneralo doxycycline monohydrate

  130. ShelbyLeW

    [url=]generic amoxicillin 500mg[/url] amoxicillin 500mg capsule

  131. RickySpupt

    [url=]amoxicillin for sale[/url] amoxicillin 500mg cost

  132. Georgeram

    online doxycycline 40mg doxycycline

  133. accutane generic – purchase zithromax tetracycline 500mg canada

  134. order generic plaquenil

  135. generic tadalafil no prescription buy tadalafil 10mg india

  136. Glenntroup

    lipitor india generic lipitor generic price canada

  137. PhilipGow

    prescription medication lipitor lipitor without prescription buy tamoxifen
    [url=]tamoxifen side effects forum[/url] tamoxifen mechanism of action

  138. [url=]cost of 1000mg metformin[/url] metformin without rx

  139. RaymondOnepe where can i buy metformin

  140. PhilipGow

    cost of tadalafil tadalafil canadian pharmacy online lipitor prescription prices
    [url=]tadalafil price uk[/url] tadalafil coupon

  141. cost cyclobenzaprine – purchase inderal online inderal uk

  142. buy rx pills online discount drugs online pharmacy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.