Is Dor Deah heretical?

Q. Is Dor Deah heretical?

 

A. There are those who would claim that Dor Deah, even all talmidei ha-Rambam, are heretics.  The cause of this accusation is their belief that the Zohar and Lurianic Kabbalah are fundamentals of the Jewish faith.  Consequently, Dor Deah’s non-acceptance of these works and the concepts that originate from them is, in their eyes, tantamount to rejection of the Jewish faith.  Dor Deah and talmide ha-Rambam are not alone in their lack of accepting Zohar or Lurianic Kabbalah as essentials of the Jewish faith.  There are other Orthodox groups, such as the followers of the Vilna Gaon and many Modern Orthodox, that would not claim non-acceptance of the Zohar equates to heresy, regardless of whether they, as individuals, personally believe that the Zohar has meaningful insights.

 

Dor Deah’s response is that whether a person or school of thought is heretical is a question of Jewish Law.  The answer to this question is to be decided according to authoritative works of halakha: one is not a heretic simply for disagreeing with a widely held aggadic interpretation, unless the Talmudic halakha specifically says so.  The Mishneh Torah is comprehensive in its scope of Talmudic law.  At the very least, it is one of the authoritative sources of Jewish Law.  It therefore follows that the Dor Deah approach must be an acceptable approach to Torah Judaism, if not a more intellectually honest approach.  Since Dor Deah asserts nothing not found within Mishneh Torah, and the Mishneh Torah cannot be interpreted as actually requiring belief in anything approaching Zoharic or Lurianic Kabbalah, Dor Deah therefore cannot be heretical – unless the Mishneh Torah itself is heretical.  And that would be a claim which no Orthodox Jewish group dare make.

 

Mesora.org recently published a book titled JUDAISM: Religion of Reason.  This book promotes and argues in favor of all the same points we make concerning pseudo-Jewish mysticism.  Interestingly, Rabbi Steven Weil, executive vice president of The Orthodox Union (OU), endorses the book as well as the website!  The OU, being one of the oldest and largest Orthodox Jewish organizations in the world, represents mainstream Orthodox Judaism.  Would the executive vice president of the OU endorse a book or website that so overtly promotes heretical views?  The Mesora website has also published the following pertinent essay, anonymous for obvious reasons:  Tohar ha-Yihud (The Oneness of G-d in its Purity).

 

It is worth noting that R’ Ovadia Yosef, the oldest leading accepted authority in Orthodox Jewish Law, despite his disagreement with our views concerning kabbalah, does not regard our views heretical.  His non-condemning view is made clear in his book M’ein Omer chapter 7 siman 93.  It is halakha that inclusion of a heretic on a beth din disqualifies the beth din, and yet R’ Ovadia Yosef voluntarily appointed R’ Yosef Kapach (listed below) to serve together with him on his rabbinical councel.

 

We have no concern for the few who rush to condemn what they do not know, who themselves tend to espouse seriously problematic hashqafa.  Should it bother a Jew that a Christian condemns him?  Why then should the condemnation of a Jew influenced by Christian thought cause us trepidation?

 

 

The following are some well known Jewish leaders of the Orthodox world who cast doubt on major aspects of what today is commonly, though mistakenly, referred to as Kabbalah:
 

Rabbi Saadiah Gaon wrote in his book Emunot v’Deot that Jews who believe in reincarnation have accepted a belief of idolatrous origins.

Maimonides (12th Century) discounted the mystical work Shiur Komah, with its starkly anthropomorphic vision of G-d, which is a popular kabbalistic text even in modern times.  In part three of the Guide for the Perplexed and chapter 71, the Rambam is unequivical that the esoteric teachings of the Sages were never written down and that, to his knowledge – as the leader of the Jewish world, had entirely disappeared.

Abraham ibn Daud, around 1110 to 1180; rejected reincarnation.

Rabbi Avraham, son of the Rambam, like his predecessors, writes at length in his book Milhhamot HaShem that the Almighty is in no way literally within time or space nor physically outside time or space, since time and space simply do not apply to His Being whatsoever. His book is almost undeniably targeted at the forbearers of much of kabbalistic thought.

Leon de Modena rejected reincarnation.

Rabbi Nissim ben Reuven (The Ran), 1320-1380; reproved the Nachmonides (Ramban) for devoting too much to kabbalah and is said to have been “no friend of mysticism.”

Yedayah Bedershi, early 14th century; rejected reincarnation.

Rabbi Yitzchak ben Sheshet Perfet (The Rivash), 1326-1408; he stated that Kabbalah was “worse than Christianity”, as it made God into 10, not just into three.

Hasdai ben Abraham Crescas, 1340-1410/11; rejected reincarnation.

Rabbi Joseph Albo, 15th century; rejected reincarnation.

Rabbi Leon Modena, a 17th century Venetian critic of Kabbalah, wrote that if we were to accept the Kabbalah, then the Christian trinity would indeed be compatible with Judaism, as the Trinity closely resembles the Kabbalistic doctrine of sefirot.

Rabbi Yaakov Emden, 1697-1776, wrote the book Mitpahhath Sfarim (Scarf / Veil of the Books) which is a detailed critique of the Zohar. He concludes that certain parts of the Zohar contain heretical teaching and therefore could not have been written by Rabbi Shimon ben Yochai. Opponents of the book claim that he wrote the book in a drunken stupor.

The ‘Chasam Sofer,’ 1762-1839, held by many to be a major establisher of  ‘Chareidi’ (black-hat) Judaism.  Ironically, the Chasam Sofer denied the authenticity and authority of the Zohar.

Rabbi Samuel Strashun, 1794-1872, in Bava Metzia 107a, in his famous commentary to the Talmud, R’ Strashun (the “Rashash” of Europe) points out a Talmudic proof against gilgulim.  A rebbi in Kol Torah put out a book called ‘dvar yakov’ on tractate bava metzia.  In commenting on this particular statement by the Rashah, the author of the book is goes off on how the Rashash could contradict “kabbalistic masters.”

Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch, 1808-1888, among other things, specified that belief in reincarnation is one of the major distinctions between what were the religious opinions (hashqafa) of the Ancient Egyptions in contrast to the religious perspective (hashqafa) of the Jewish Faith.  He writes that reincarnation was central to the Egyptian Faith.

Rabbi Yihhyah Qafih, the early 20th century chief rabbi of Yemenite Jewry wrote a book called Milhhamoth HaShem, (Wars of the LORD) against anti-Torah teachings of the Zohar and “Lurianic Kabbalah.”

Nechama Leibowitz, 1905-1997; renown modern scholar and commentator to the Tanakh – avoided making use of kabbalistic works in her popular commentaries.

Yeshayahu Leibowitz 1903-1994, brother of Nechama Leibowitz; he publicly shared and supported views expressed in Rabbi Yihhyah Qafih‘s book Milhhamoth HaShem that much of popular ‘kabbala’ is idolatrious; was against allowing kabbalistic texts to influence halakhic practice.

Rabbi Yosef Kapach taught against allowing kabbalistic texts to influence halakhic practice.

Rabbi Jose Faur takes a traditional rationalist approach in understanding Talmud.  He has written numerous articles on the historical Christian influences on what has now become the standard form of “yeshivish Chareidi” Judaism.  He has been consistant in pointing out that these influences entered the Jewish world in the guise of pseudo-Jewish mysticism.  Those who feel threatened by his research have spread baseless hatred against him, with claims that he is a member of the Conservative Movement and a heretic.  Even following these unfounded accusations, Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu stated the when asked concerning him: “the greatest Sephardic Hacham living in the US today is Rabbi Faur.”

 

 

R’ Yosef Eliyah

 

 

 

* DorDeah.com is an independent organization.  DorDeah.com is not affiliated with www.mechon-mamre.org, the “Torath Moshe Society,” nor Chabad-Lubavitch.  Though we are grateful for the contributions of these organizations in providing Mishne Torah resources, we do not endorse all the views espoused by these organizations.

Post navigation

125 Comments
  1. female cialis 10mg

    Wow, amazing blog structure! How long have you ever been running
    a blog for? you make running a blog look easy.

    The full glance of your website is excellent, let alone the content!

  2. Takcmw [url=https://oscialipop.com]cialis tadalafil[/url] Cialis Forum Priligy 2 Levitra 10 Rover Orodispersible https://oscialipop.com – cialis 20 mg

  3. Montetraps

    [url=http://cheapdrugs.store/#]erectial dysfunction[/url]

  4. Jamesappex

    viagra vs cialis bodybuilding ed drugs list ed treatment review

  5. Jamesappex

    buy cialis online canada cialis 20 mg best price brand cialis canada

  6. Jamesappex

    how can i order prednisone order prednisone prednisone 50 mg tablet canada

  7. Jamesappex

    prednisone 1 mg for sale buy cheap prednisone best pharmacy prednisone

  8. Jamesappex

    buy prescription drugs without doctor best erection pills erectile dysfunction treatments

  9. Jamesappex

    how to take cialis 5mg cialis can you take cialis in the morning and viagra at night

  10. viagra alternatives viagra from canada pharmacy sildenafil over the counter cvs

  11. Jamesappex

    buy cialis on line purchasing cialis in the usa is cialis covered by insurance

  12. You made various good points there. I did a search on the matter and found mainly folks will go along with with your blog.

  13. GregoryOrada

    stromectol cheap ivermectin and dexamethasone stromectol pills

  14. cialis otc switch cialis cheap online cialis cvs

  15. GregoryOrada

    liquid ivermectin dosage for humans price of ivermectin purchase stromectol

  16. GregoryOrada

    ed meds online without prescription or membership prescription drugs without doctor approval discount prescription drugs

  17. GregoryOrada

    oral ivermectin ivermectin rabbits stromectol australia

  18. viagra for womens where to buy viagra buy best generic viagra

  19. GregoryOrada

    ivermectin pill for lice pig wormer ivermectin pour on ivermectin for horses tractor supply

  20. GregoryOrada

    best otc ed pills ed treatments medications for ed

  21. GregoryOrada

    generic propecia no prescription propecia 5mg sale buy propecia uk

  22. stromectol for sale stromectol pills for humans stromectol for sale

  23. non prescription ed drugs men’s ed pills non prescription ed drugs

  24. generic ed drugs medicine for erectile ed pill

  25. modafinil 100mg uk cheap provigil

  26. generic drugs without doctor’s prescription reputable online pharmacies in india india pharmacies online

  27. buy modafinil 200mg online buy provigil 200mg online cheap

  28. order modafinil 100mg online cheap buy provigil 200mg generic

  29. Douglasrow

    stromectol without a doctor prescription stromectol for sale prescribing stromectol

  30. buy modafinil for sale order provigil 100mg online

  31. Douglasrow

    sildenafil viagra tablets for men sildenafil citrate tablets 100 mg

  32. provigil 100mg without prescription modafinil sale

  33. Douglasrow

    lowest price tadalafil price of cialis 20 mg buy tadalafil online

  34. order provigil buy provigil online cheap provigil buy online

  35. Douglasrow

    stromectol for sale stromectol price usa prescribing stromectol

  36. Douglasrow

    stromectol for sale stromectol without a doctor prescription stromectol 12 mg tablets

  37. provigil 100mg tablet order provigil 100mg pill order modafinil online

  38. provigil 100mg sale modafinil 200mg cost

  39. Douglasrow

    cialis pharmacy generic tadalafil 20mg india cialis coupon

  40. EugeneDub

    ivermectin and cancer stromectol for humans for sale ivermectin dosage human

  41. cheap modafinil 100mg buy generic provigil 200mg order provigil

  42. EugeneDub

    what is stromectol stromectol for sale petsmart ivermectin

  43. EugeneDub

    stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for sale

  44. houston junk car buyer

    Howdy! I know this is kind of off-topic however I needed to ask.
    Does building a well-established blog like yours require a massive amount work?
    I am completely new to operating a blog however I do
    write in my journal on a daily basis. I’d like to
    start a blog so I can share my own experience and views online.
    Please let me know if you have any suggestions or tips for brand
    new aspiring bloggers. Appreciate it!

  45. Raymondgoock

    online doctor prescription for viagra viagra buy viagra online usa

  46. Raymondgoock

    how much is viagra sildenafil 100 mg buy viagra online canada

  47. Raymondgoock

    viagra without a doctor prescription usa viagra pills where can i buy viagra over the counter

  48. Robertacifs

    cialis on line new zealand generic tadalafil 20mg india cialis and viagra

  49. Robertacifs

    cialis coupon voucher generic cialis for daily use black tab cialis

  50. You are one talented writer thank you for the post.

  51. Wish I’d thought of this. Am in the field, but I procrastinate alot and haven’t written as much as I’d like. Thanks.

  52. Appreciation for taking the time to discuss this topic, I would love to discover more on this topic. If viable, as you gain expertise, would you object to updating the website with further information? It is tremendously beneficial for me.

  53. Robertacifs

    cialis soft tabs 20mg tadalafil how much is cialis without insurance

  54. Thank you, I have just been searching for information about this topic for ages and yours is the greatest I’ve discovered till now. But, what about the conclusion? Are you sure about the source?

  55. I think I might disagree with some of your analysis. Are the figures solid?

  56. I wanted to check up and let you know how, a great deal I cherished discovering your blog today. I might consider it an honor to work at my office and be able to utilize the tips provided on your blog and also be a part of visitors’ reviews like this. Should a position associated with guest writer become on offer at your end, make sure you let me know.

  57. Robertacifs

    cialis over the counter 2018 price of cialis 20 mg online doctor cialis

  58. Robertacifs

    buy generic cialis in canada tadalafil 20mg cialis dominican resort

  59. Robertacifs

    cialis side effects a wife′s perspective best price for daily cialis cialis online overnight

  60. http://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin topical solution

  61. Cherished is likely to be what people say about your comments.

  62. Top magazine for business executives in Oceania

    Thank you for the auspicious writeup.

  63. RalphEdirl

    can you buy cialis with no prescription cialis

  64. ventolin interactions site salbutamol brand

  65. ivermectin price comparison generic ivermectin

  66. StromTWirm

    [url=https://stromectolgf.online/#]generic ivermectin cream[/url] ivermectin oral 0 8

  67. order priligy dapoxetine buy dapoxetine buy priligy online india

  68. https://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin eye ointment for cats

  69. water bottle dog toy

    It’s the best time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you some interesting things or tips. Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!

  70. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/#]ed meds online without doctor prescription[/url] ed meds online without doctor prescription

  71. StevenRon

    https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/# ed meds online without doctor prescription

  72. RalphEdirl

    cialis 10mg canada best price for daily cialis

  73. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/#]buy prescription drugs from canada[/url] prescription drugs

  74. erythromycin 500mg erythromycin ophthalmic

  75. dewalt electric chainsaw

    Of course, what a great site and informative posts, I will add backlink – bookmark this site? Regards, Reader

  76. plaquenil for sale online hydroxychloroquine 200mg buy

  77. Jamisontog

    viagra cost viagra from canada
    https://sildenafilmg.com/ viagra over the counter
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]viagra cost[/url] viagra from canada

  78. best women workout clothes

    Awesome post. It’s so good to see someone taking the time to share this information

  79. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# viagra from india

  80. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]buy real viagra online[/url] buy generic 100mg viagra online

  81. Jamisontog

    mexican viagra viagra
    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]best over the counter viagra[/url] online doctor prescription for viagra

  82. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# viagra 100mg price

  83. free rdp for mac

    I just couldnt leave your website before saying that I really enjoyed the useful information you offer to your visitors… Will be back often to check up on new stuff you post!

  84. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]where to buy viagra[/url] cost of viagra

  85. Jamisontog

    cheap viagra online sildenafil 20 mg
    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# viagra online usa
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]sildenafil 20 mg[/url] best place to buy generic viagra online

  86. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# buy generic 100mg viagra online

  87. sexy tops for women

    You have some helpful ideas! Maybe I should consider doing this by myself.

  88. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]sildenafil[/url] viagra online usa

  89. fifa world cup live free

    It’s continually awesome when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I’m sure you had fun writing this article. Regards, Clotilde.

  90. fifa world cup live free

    I would share your post with my sis.

  91. watch thor love and thunder online

    Hi there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing several weeks of hard work due to no back up. Do you have any solutions to protect against hackers?

  92. Jamisontog

    viagra cost viagra
    https://sildenafilmg.com/ how much is viagra
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]sildenafil[/url] viagra online usa

  93. Georgeram

    clomid 50 mg tablet price in india clomid 150mg

  94. cheap rdp

    I loved your idea there, I tell you blogs are so exciting sometimes like looking into people’s private life’s and work. Every new remark wonderful in its own right.

  95. rdp admin access

    How do I subscribe to your blog? Thanks for your help.

  96. where can i buy zithromax medicine zithromax drug
    https://doxycyclineforsale.life/# doxycycline cream over the counter
    [url=https://zithromaxforsale.shop/#]where can i buy zithromax capsules[/url] purchase zithromax z-pak

  97. Robertzet

    buy doxycycline 100mg capsule buy doxycycline 100mg online uk

  98. Stepheneralo

    https://clomidforsale.life/# clomid india buy

  99. Georgeram

    doxycycline online usa where can i get doxycycline

  100. ShelbyLeW

    [url=https://doxycyclineforsale.life/#]doxycycline 50 mg tablets price[/url] antibiotic doxycycline

  101. RaymondOnepe

    prednisone generic cost prednisone cost canada

  102. Stepheneralo

    https://prednisoneforsale.store/# prednisone 50 mg coupon

  103. Robertzet

    generic doxycycline 200 mg 10 doxycycline gel

  104. RickySpupt

    [url=https://clomidforsale.life/#]clomid iui[/url] clomid for sale

  105. hydroxychloroquine for sale online hydroxychloroquine mexico pharmacy

  106. ufc 276 live

    A friend of mine advised this site. And yes. it has some useful pieces of info and I enjoyed scaning it. Therefore i would love to drop you a quick note to express my thank. Take care

  107. PhilipGow

    metformin 500mg tablets price in india metformin xl
    https://buymetformin.best/# how to order metformin online
    [url=https://buynolvadex.store/#]tamoxifen[/url] nolvadex during cycle

  108. [url=https://buylipitor.store/#]lipitor 4 mg[/url] lipitor tablets

  109. RaymondOnepe

    https://buytadalafil.men/# tadalafil generic over the counter

  110. PhilipGow

    lasix online lasix uses
    https://buylipitor.store/# lipitor lowest price
    [url=https://buytadalafil.men/#]generic tadalafil united states[/url] tadalafil 5mg cost

  111. watch jurassic world dominion online

    We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in our community. Your blog provided us with valuable information to work on|.You have done a marvellous job!

  112. NFT Generator

    What made you first develop an interest in this topic?

  113. EdwardPluch

    lasix tablet lasix tablet

  114. Anthonyclorn

    https://buynolvadex.store/# does tamoxifen cause joint pain

  115. [url=https://buymetformin.best/#]buy metformin 1000 mg without prescription[/url] metformin tablet price in india

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.