Isn’t Dor Deah reminiscent of Islamic fundamentalism?

 

Q:

Isn’t Dor Deah reminiscent of Islamic fundamentalism?

 

A:

5. A final criticism is that the Dor Dai version of Judaism is disquietingly reminiscent of militant Islamic trends such as Salafism. Both started out as modernising movements designed to remove some of the cobwebs and allow the religion to compete in the modern world, and both have ended up as fundamentalist groups lending themselves to alliances with political extremism. Both disapprove of mysticism (Kabbalah or Sufism) and praying at tombs; both tend to dismiss more moderate coreligionists as unbelievers (see Takfir); both cut out centuries of sophisticated legal scholarship in favour of an every-man-for-himself “back to the sources” approach.

The Dor Daim answer to this is:

  1. Political militancy is no more characteristic of Dor Daim than of many Kabbalistically-inspired branches of Religious Zionism (e.g. the followers of Zvi Yehuda Kook). In fact the conditions for political or military action, as laid down in the Mishneh Torah, are extremely strict and limited.
  2. Neither Dor Daim nor talmide ha-Rambam are against mysticism per se: see Attitude to Kabbalah above. The attitude to Kabbalah is based on much more specific factors: if there is an analogue to their opposition among other religions, it is essentially an opposition to the espousal of concepts such as incarnationpantheism, and panentheism – apart from the opposition to idolatry in general, as understood in the context of the Mishneh Torah.
  3. The antagonism shared by Dor Daim and talmide ha-Rambam against praying at tombs etc. is distinct from the Salafi view in a number of ways. First, in contrast to the Salafi view, the Dor Dai / talmide ha-Rambam view is that this prohibition is Rabbinic, meaning that it is not a direct command from the Almighty, but rather it is a “fence” to distance a Jew from the possibility of transgressing a more severe prohibition. They do not consider praying at or visiting a tomb to be idolatry, nor do they believe that this is prohibited to all people (i.e. non-Israelites), whereas the Salafi view is that this is forbidden to everyone as a very severe prohibition in itself.
  4. It is wrong to accuse Dor Daim and talmide ha-Rambamof being extremists, or of dismissing more moderate coreligionists as unbelievers: see reply to 2 above. On the contrary, they often find more in common theologically with sectors of Modern Orthodoxy than they do with much of the Ḥasidic or Ḥaredi communities.
  5. The method of learning and religious observance aimed at by them is firmly rooted in Jewish rabbinic authority (see Jewish law above), and is about as far from an “every-man-for-himself” approach as it is possible to get. How far a similar accusation may be true of Salafism (which is itself an umbrella description for a great many trends) is an independent question, on which Dor Daim are not required to express a view.
  6. Salafis typically reject Islamic philosophy of the kind propounded by Avicenna and Averroes. Dor Daim, by contrast, find strong inspiration in the closely related Jewish philosophies of Bahya ibn Pakuda and Maimonides.
  7. Many Dor Daim and talmide ha-Rambam desire that the Jewish people as a nation will return to upholding the Almighty’s Torah with the establishment of a central religious authority – a Great Court (Sanhedrin) reestablished according to Jewish law as only fully codified in the Mishneh Torah. That is one form of the Messianic aspiration implicit in any form of Orthodox Judaism. It cannot be compared to the desire of some Islamists to reestablish a Khilafah by violent means if necessary.

Post navigation

103 Comments
  1. kbc lottery winner list 2022

    platform as yours and I’m having difficulty finding one?

  2. kbc lottery winner list 2022

    with almost all significant infos.

  3. Montetraps

    [url=http://cheapdrugs.store/#]ed cures[/url]

  4. Jamesappex

    best place to buy generic cialis cialis cheap cialis online overnight shipping

  5. Jamesappex

    ivermectin scabies treatment ivermectin injection for rabbits buy stromectol

  6. Jamesappex

    new ed drugs erection problems pumps for ed

  7. Jamesappex

    fast shipping prednisone cheap prednisone prednisone 2.5 mg daily

  8. Jamesappex

    ed pumps top ed drugs best medicine for ed

  9. Jamesappex

    how much is prednisone 10 mg order prednisone prednisone otc uk

  10. Jamesappex

    where can you buy prednisone prednisone for sale prednisone 20mg tablets where to buy

  11. GregoryOrada

    ivermectin ticks ivermectin for scaly leg mites ivermectin for heartworm prevention

  12. GregoryOrada

    how much ivermectin to give a 50lb dog ivermectin 6 mg tablets why is stromectol prescribed

  13. GregoryOrada

    ivermectin ivermectin eczema п»їwhere to buy stromectol online

  14. GregoryOrada

    ed treatments treatments for ed compare ed drugs

  15. GregoryOrada

    finasteride medication buy propecia online buy finasteride no rx

  16. GregoryOrada

    best ed treatment ed pills online buy erection pills

  17. GregoryOrada

    treatments for ed erectile dysfunction medications non prescription ed drugs

  18. canadian pharmacy online ship to usa canadian pharmaceuticals online safe canadian pharmaceuticals online safe

  19. overseas pharmacies online india pharmacies online overseas pharmacies online

  20. stromectol for sale stromectol stromectol 3 mg tablets price

  21. order provigil 200mg pills order modafinil 100mg online order modafinil 200mg for sale

  22. online pharmacy india buy prescription online from india india pharmacies online

  23. https://erythromycinn.com/# erythromycin eye ointment

  24. modafinil sale buy modafinil 200mg online cheap

  25. provigil uk cheap modafinil

  26. Douglasrow

    clomid for sale canada buy clomid clomid for sale

  27. Douglasrow

    stromectol 3 mg tablets price prescribing stromectol stromectol without a doctor prescription

  28. order modafinil generic provigil ca provigil 200mg us

  29. Douglasrow

    tadalafil best price 20 mg tadalafil best price 20 mg price of cialis 20 mg

  30. modafinil 100mg sale provigil 100mg pill

  31. Douglasrow

    viagra tablets for men viagra where to buy sildenafil 100 mg

  32. provigil 200mg usa modafinil canada

  33. order modafinil 200mg sale order provigil 100mg generic

  34. Douglasrow

    stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol stromectol 12 mg tablets

  35. order modafinil 100mg online cheap order provigil 100mg pill provigil 100mg us

  36. buy modafinil pills order modafinil 200mg online purchase provigil for sale

  37. Douglasrow

    stromectol for humans for sale ivermectin without a doctor prescription stromectol for sale

  38. EugeneDub

    stromectol 12 mg tablets ivermectin for dogs fleas stromectol for sale

  39. EugeneDub

    stromectol for humans for sale ivermectin side effects stromectol for humans for sale

  40. erythromycin for fish tanks erythromycin ophth ointment 3.5 gm

  41. EugeneDub

    stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol for sale stromectol for humans for sale

  42. Raymondgoock

    where to buy viagra online doctor prescription for viagra buy viagra online usa

  43. Raymondgoock

    buy generic 100mg viagra online viagra buy viagra online usa

  44. Raymondgoock

    cost of viagra viagra coupon viagra over the counter walmart

  45. Robertacifs

    cialis peru tadalafil 20mg best price generic cialis 40mg

  46. erythromycin ingredients https://erythromycin1m.com/#

  47. Robertacifs

    when to take cialis for best results cialis pills buy cialis 20 mg

  48. Robertacifs

    buy cialis pay with paypal canada tadalafil 20mg best price viagra vs cialis vs levitra

  49. Robertacifs

    п»їcialis best price for daily cialis cialis medication

  50. Robertacifs

    brand cialis with prescription cialis free cialis

  51. erythromycin ophthalmic ointment usp 0.5 http://erythromycin1m.com/#

  52. Robertacifs

    cialis without prescribtion cialis buy cialis from canadian pharmacy

  53. RalphEdirl

    cialis black 800 to buy in the uk one pill cialis pills

  54. StromTWirm

    [url=https://stromectolgf.com/#]ivermectin brand name[/url] ivermectin 5 mg

  55. http://erythromycin1m.com/# erythromycin benzoyl gel reviews

  56. Chesterswogy

    https://stromectolgf.com/# stromectol pills

  57. stromectol online ivermectin brand name

  58. erythromycin for fish tanks erythromycin eye ointment dosage

  59. StevenRon

    https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/# п»їed drugs online from canada

  60. CameronFeedy

    best online canadian pharmacy prescription meds without the prescriptions

  61. RalphEdirl

    cialis soft tabs online best price for daily cialis

  62. CameronFeedy

    prescription drugs online without doctor canadian drug pharmacy

  63. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.online/#]prescription drugs[/url] best canadian online pharmacy

  64. StevenRon

    https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/# ed meds online without doctor prescription

  65. RalphEdirl

    best online pharmacy for cialis generic cialis fast shipping

  66. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/#]buy prescription drugs from canada[/url] canadian drug pharmacy

  67. Jamisontog

    best place to buy viagra online viagra for men
    https://sildenafilmg.com/ viagra price
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]viagra pills[/url] buying viagra online

  68. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]viagra 100mg price[/url] buy real viagra online

  69. BrandonLaf

    buy viagra online usa viagra price

  70. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# viagra 100mg price

  71. order plaquenil online hydroxychloroquine online otc

  72. Jamisontog

    over the counter viagra viagra pills
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# cost of viagra
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra shop[/url] viagra cost

  73. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]best over the counter viagra[/url] online doctor prescription for viagra

  74. BrandonLaf

    best place to buy viagra online how much is viagra

  75. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# best place to buy viagra online

  76. BrandonLaf

    viagra discount sildenafil

  77. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]buy generic 100mg viagra online[/url] where to buy viagra

  78. Jamisontog

    buy viagra online canada viagra for men
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# buying viagra online
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]viagra amazon[/url] viagra without a doctor prescription usa

  79. BrandonLaf

    over the counter viagra buy real viagra online

  80. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra shop[/url] buy viagra online usa

  81. Jamisontog

    how much is viagra viagra coupons 75% off
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# viagra discount
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]viagra coupons 75% off[/url] viagra over the counter

  82. Georgeram

    doxycycline 40 mg 3626 doxycycline

  83. Robertzet

    where can i get clomid pills clomid generic otc

  84. Georgeram

    cost of generic zithromax how to get zithromax online

  85. RaymondOnepe

    where to get zithromax zithromax capsules price

  86. RickySpupt

    [url=https://zithromaxforsale.shop/#]where can i get zithromax[/url] zithromax online australia

  87. ShelbyLeW

    [url=https://clomidforsale.life/#]where can i buy clomid tablets[/url] clomid buy

  88. Georgeram

    prednisone 30 mg daily prednisone 50 mg tablet canada

  89. amoxicillin online pharmacy cost of amoxicillin 30 capsules
    https://clomidforsale.life/# best over the counter clomid
    [url=https://clomidforsale.life/#]where to buy clomid in singapore[/url] where can you buy clomid over the counter

  90. Stepheneralo

    https://zithromaxforsale.shop/# buy zithromax no prescription

  91. Robertzet

    where can i buy clomid medicine clomid buy

  92. www.xmc.pl

    I enjoy the spirit of , but have a couple of qualms regarding this shibboleth.

  93. PhilipGow

    furosemida 40 mg lasix uses
    https://buynolvadex.store/# tamoxifen moa
    [url=https://buynolvadex.store/#]tamoxifen depression[/url] tamoxifen medication

  94. RickySpupt

    generic lipitor buy cheap lipitor
    https://buylasix.icu/# lasix 100mg
    [url=https://buymetformin.best/#]metformin.com[/url] metformin 1000mg without prescription

  95. RaymondOnepe

    https://buylipitor.store/# lipitor purchase

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.