Why don’t Jews accept the Islamic Jesus?

 

When the Quran refers to Jesus as the messiah, what is it attributing to him that it doesn’t attribute to other prophets?

 

The Qur’an (4:171) applies the term Messiah, maseeyHto Jesus the son of Mary.  In the Hebrew language, the word Messiah, masheeyaH, literally means anointed.

 

The Hebrew Bible applies this term to the high-priests and proper kings of Israel, because they were anointed: a fact that is lost in most translations, due to inconsistently translating the term as ‘messiah’ where it would strengthen Christian theology, and translating it as ‘anointed’ in all other places.

 

In Hebrew, being called ‘messiah’ does not make one unique among the other high-priests and kings of Israel.

 

The only context in which Jews gave the term ‘messiah’ special significance, is when in reference to the king of Israel who will eventually arise and lead the people of Israel to lasting spiritual restoration, together with the rest of the world as Moses prophesied towards the end of the Book of Deuteronomy.  G-d promised to King David that a male descendent of his royal line will be the one to establish the everlasting kingdom of G-d on earth.  Consequently, the Muslim apologetic responses that all the term ‘messiah‘ means in reference to Jesus is that he was blessed or was a preacher, are unconvincing.  How would this make him any more unique than the numerous prophets before him who were blessed and were preachers?  Likewise, the explanation that the term ‘messiah‘ only means that Jesus was the final prophet of Israel, is likewise unconvincing.  There is no precedent for understanding the word ‘messiah’ in this way.  No such use of the term predates Islamic apologetics.  And significantly, the Qur’an itself never makes this claim.  As for the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament, both the Jewish Scriptures (Joel 3:1-2) and the Christian Scriptures make it quite clear that prophets would yet be among the people of Israel even after the Messiah;  (Acts 11:27, 13:1, 15:32-33; 1 Corinth. 12:28; Eph. 4:11).

 

This raises another difficulty – the ‘virgin birth.’  The Qur’an (3:45, 3:47, 3:59, 66:12) affirms the Christian belief in the virgin birth of Jesus.  The POSSIBILITY of a virgin birth is not in itself an issue.  Certainly the Creator of the universe can cause a woman to enter pregnancy without having relations with a man. But for one familiar with the Hebrew Bible, the virgin birth is problematic for other reasons:

 

The necessity of the virgin birth is based on a terrible MIS-understanding of Isaiah chapter 7.  Besides misunderstanding the context of ch. 7, the entire concept of the virgin-birth depends on an early mistranslation of the Hebrew word ‘alma by means of the word virgin. ‘alma refers to a young adolescent female, but it does NOT mean virgin.  The same Christian translators who incorrectly translate ‘alma as virgin consistently correctly translate the male form of this word as merely young adolescent or youth.  Why do they never translate the male version of this word as virgin boy?  Inconsistency is the sign of error.  The Hebrew prophets did not teach that the messiah would be born from a virgin.  If they had wanted to teach such a concept in Isaiah 7, the Hebrew word betula would have been used, not ‘alma.  Incidentally, Muslims should be among the last to fall the Christian polemic that betula was not used because it doesn’t mean virgin; for aside from the fact that Jewish preservation of the Hebrew language says that betula means virgin, this word also means virgin in Arabic!

 

The 2nd difficulty is even more problematic:

 

– if Jesus did not have a human father, then he can not be the promised future king of King David’s royal line. Why? Because the royal ancestry goes according to one’s father, both according to Torah-law and according to human practice in general. Even if Jesus was a great man or a prophet, he could not have been the messiah if he had no human father.

 

Another reason why the mention of Jesus as a prophet and messiah in the Quran makes it difficult for Jews to unquestionably accept the Quran is because, at least as it is TYPICALLY understand, the Quran teaches that the Torah has been corrupted and therefore is no longer reliable – but Jesus promised that the Torah (the Law of Moses) will be PRESERVED, even the SMALLEST details of the text of the Torah would remain in tact! (Mat. 5:17-18).  In addition to this, the New Testament records that Jesus taught that one should NOT think that he came to nullify the laws of the Torah. Rather, ‘whoever teaches that even the least of these commands are nullified, the same shall be the least in the kingdom of heaven.‘ (Mat. 5:19)

 

The earliest students of Jesus likewise did not intend to abandon the laws of the Torah; (Acts 6:13-14Acts 21:20-24)  Ironically, the teachings which the New Testament Book of Acts catagorizes as a ‘false report’ concerning the teachings of Jesus’ followers, is now the official doctrine of Christianity.  The original followers of Jesus did not think that after Jesus arrived the laws of the Torah were no longer binding.  To the contrary, their question was whether even non-Israelite followers of Jesus need to keep all the laws of Moses.  The New Test. teaches that they decided that since the non-Jewish followers of Jesus would be learning from the Torah read every week in the synagogue, therefore they need not be required to observe all the laws of Moses as a prerequisite to being accepted among the believers.  Only a preliminary code of conduct need be observed — (Acts 15:1-2, 13-22).

 

And thus we find many ancient references to Jewish followers of Jesus even hundreds of years after Jesus’ departure, that they continued to keep the laws of the Torah of Moses. They expected that Jesus would return at any moment to restore the people of Israel and the world – without thinking that this in any way implies that the commandments of Moses would be nullified or replaced. Indeed, to think that the repentance of the people of Israel includes abandonment of the laws of Moses or that the laws of Moses would at that time be nullified or replaced, is equivalent to REJECTING the prophets of Israel. For the prophets of Israel state that when the people of Israel as a whole are restored, all of Israel will return to keeping the laws of Moses and all nations will serve G-d and prostrate to Him in Jerusalem (Zech 14,16-17; Isaiah 66,10-23).

 

It is because Jews ACCEPT all the previous prophets that they are not easily convinced of certain details in the Quran.  Among other things, we would first need to be convinced that Jesus’ promise that the Torah will be preserved and that it’s commandments are still valid – that these are merely LATER corruptions of Jesus’ message… but it is unbelievable that these statements are later corruptions added by the early Christian Church.  These statements only weaken the claims of Christianity.  Torah is G-d’s eternal guidance for all mankind.

 

R’ Yosef Eliyah

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KHQcy3evDZc

Post navigation

160 Comments
  1. Montetraps

    [url=http://cheapdrugs.store/#]cause of ed[/url]

  2. sildenafil usa – genuine viagra sildenafil 100mg canada

  3. Williamboato

    ivermectin 3 mg tablet tab ivermectin 12 mg ivermectin 8000

  4. Williamboato

    buy prednisone online no script generic prednisone purchase prednisone 10mg

  5. Williamboato

    pain meds without written prescription ed natural remedies errection problem cure

  6. Williamboato

    how to purchase prednisone online generic prednisone prednisone 5 mg

  7. prednisolone 40mg brand – neurontin 600mg brand buy generic cialis

  8. Williamboato

    doctors for erectile dysfunction best ed drug impotence treatment

  9. Williamboato

    best treatment for ed male ed pills medications online

  10. Williamboato

    buy cialis 36 hour cialis usa prescription cialis free sample

  11. CharlesMaimi

    propecia generic finasteride hair cheap propecia

  12. order augmentin 625mg online – cialis 40mg cheap oral cialis 10mg

  13. CharlesMaimi

    where to buy propecia cost of propecia cheap generic propecia

  14. CharlesMaimi

    how do i get propecia is propecia a prescription drug propecia prescription online

  15. buy bactrim – order viagra online buy viagra online cheap

  16. CharlesMaimi

    male ed pills ed drug prices best treatment for ed

  17. CharlesMaimi

    compare ed drugs male erection pills ed treatment drugs

  18. CharlesMaimi

    propecia 5 mg buy propecia uk propecia women

  19. CharlesMaimi

    ivermectin injection for dogs ivermectin treatment ivermectin 1mg

  20. purchase cephalexin generic – order erythromycin online cheap erythromycin 250mg

  21. Canadaskymn

    generic drugs without doctor’s prescription buy prescription drugs online cheap order prescriptions online without doctor

  22. Canadaskymn

    legitimate online pharmacies india best online international pharmacies india overseas pharmacies online

  23. Canadaskymn

    ed medications best pills for ed pills for ed

  24. fildena 100mg oral – fildena generic stromectol medication

  25. order modafinil 200mg generic modafinil uk brand provigil 100mg

  26. Canadaskymn

    cheapest ed pills treatments for ed pills for ed

  27. provigil over the counter provigil cheap

  28. buy modafinil online provigil generic purchase provigil for sale

  29. order modafinil 100mg without prescription cost provigil buy generic provigil

  30. order rhinocort generic – cialis 10mg pill antabuse online buy

  31. MichaelVof

    viagra pills price for viagra viagra where to buy

  32. provigil 200mg usa provigil 100mg pills provigil cheap

  33. MichaelVof

    stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for sale stromectol for sale

  34. MichaelVof

    stromectol stromectol without a doctor prescription stromectol 3 mg tablets price

  35. ceftin 500mg over the counter – purchase ceftin pills buy tadalafil 10mg for sale

  36. cost provigil 200mg modafinil canada provigil pills

  37. erythromycin opthalmic ointment erythromycin ophthalmic eye drops

  38. brand modafinil 200mg modafinil 100mg ca

  39. modafinil 200mg uk order modafinil 100mg

  40. MichaelVof

    cialis 20mg cialis online purchase of tadalafil in india

  41. MichaelVof

    stromectol for sale ivermectin without a doctor prescription prescribing stromectol

  42. modafinil 200mg drug buy modafinil pills

  43. ampicillin 250mg sale – cialis 10mg cheap order generic cialis 20mg

  44. MichaelVof

    clomid for sale clomid tablets for sale clomid tablets

  45. provigil 200mg us modafinil 200mg cost

  46. MichaelVof

    stromectol for humans for sale stromectol stromectol for sale

  47. modafinil 200mg cheap buy provigil online cheap

  48. ivermectin heartworms stromectol for sale ivermectin paste for ear mites in horses

  49. ivermectin spray stromectol online pharmacy stromectol for humans for sale

  50. amoxicillin online order – amoxicillin drug buy levitra 20mg pills

  51. stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for sale

  52. ivermectin cost australia stromectol for humans for sale stromectol 12 mg tablets

  53. stromectol us – order vardenafil purchase vardenafil pill

  54. viagra online usa viagra best place to buy generic viagra online

  55. buy real viagra online viagra tablets for men viagra price

  56. doxycycline pills – buy clomiphene for sale tadalafil 10mg cost

  57. Andrewfet

    take cialis the correct way tadalafil 20mg typical cialis prescription strength

  58. Andrewfet

    cialis canadian price of cialis 20 mg gneric cialis

  59. Andrewfet

    buy cialis 20 mg cialis pills generic cialis from canada

  60. http://erythromycinn.com/# clindamycin vs erythromycin

  61. cheap tadalafil pills – provigil uk buy modafinil generic

  62. Andrewfet

    cialis hk best price for daily cialis arghentina cialis

  63. Andrewfet

    cialis professional 20 lowest price generic version of cialis original cialis com

  64. prednisone 5mg cheap – order prednisone 10mg pill buy isotretinoin generic

  65. Andrewfet

    gneric cialis generic tadalafil 20mg india where can i buy cialis

  66. order amoxil 250mg generic – buy generic sildenafil 150mg sildenafil viagra

  67. erythromycin allergy http://erythromycinn.com/#

  68. buy prednisolone 20mg – neurontin tablets sildenafil 50mg without prescription

  69. lasix online order – doxycycline brand cost of stromectol medication

  70. g5mcy

    nf9k4

    63v0

  71. erythromycin oint erythromycin eye

  72. plaquenil 400mg without prescription – chloroquine without prescription cost baricitinib

  73. stromectol cost
    stromectol
    is ivermectin safe for people
    [url=https://stromectolik.com/]stromectol 6mg[/url]

  74. 3d3ed

    vhwx6

    [url=http://novrazbb.com/#]oic2[/url]

  75. RalphEdirl

    where to buy cialis in singapore tadalafil

  76. order glucophage online cheap – atorvastatin 80mg generic buy norvasc 5mg pill

  77. StromTWirm

    [url=https://stromectolgf.online/#]stromectol online[/url] stromectol south africa

  78. stromectol where to buy ivermectin 200mg

  79. lisinopril uk – order metoprolol 50mg online cheap order atenolol 100mg online

  80. lasix generic
    lasix dosage
    lasix side effects
    [url=https://furosemidevs.com/]lasix pills 20 mg[/url]
    how much lasix can you take daily

  81. jfu1v

    hy7go

    pprq

  82. order levitra 10mg pills – vardenafil over the counter generic clomiphene

  83. RalphEdirl

    cialis super active 20 mg cialis pills

  84. ventolin hfa 90 mcg inhaler dosage
    over the counter asthma inhaler
    buy asthma inhalers without an rx
    [url=https://ventolinusa.com/]albuterol sulfate hfa ventolin hfa[/url]

  85. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/#]buy prescription drugs from canada[/url] how to get prescription drugs without doctor

  86. StevenRon

    https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/# how to get prescription drugs without doctor

  87. CameronFeedy

    prescription drugs without prior prescription online prescription for ed meds

  88. albuterol ca – purchase ventolin inhalator online dapoxetine sale

  89. buy cheap viagra and cialis lady viagra tablet buy viagra zurich

  90. cheap viagra canada online buy viagra online new zealand

  91. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/#]carprofen without vet prescription[/url] best online canadian pharmacy

  92. CameronFeedy

    buy prescription drugs from india buy prescription drugs without doctor

  93. Russellprive

    https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/ prescription drugs canada buy online

  94. BradleyCobre

    how to get prescription drugs without doctor discount prescription drugs

  95. DavidWinna

    how to get prescription drugs without doctor buy prescription drugs without doctor

  96. Michaelcal

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/#]prescription meds without the prescriptions[/url] canadian pharmacy online

  97. synthroid uk – plaquenil 400mg tablet oral hydroxychloroquine

  98. zithromax 500mg

    priligy at walgreens [url=http://priligy.site/#]cost of priligy [/url] took priligy to soon how do you take priligy

  99. tadalafil 10mg sale – cialis 5mg over the counter buy viagra 100mg without prescription

  100. can you buy albuterol

    order cialis viagra online canadian pharmacy can a female take male viagra how to use viagra 100mg tablet

  101. albuterol hfa inhaler 8g generic proventil inhaler

  102. plaquenil online cheap plaquenil plaquenil 200mg bid

  103. buy prednisone 10mg generic – order orlistat for sale amoxil 250mg sale

  104. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra[/url] how much is viagra

  105. Jamisontog

    viagra cost per pill sildenafil
    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# order viagra online
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]sildenafil[/url] viagra amazon

  106. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# where to buy viagra online

  107. diltiazem price – buy diltiazem 180mg for sale buy gabapentin 800mg without prescription

  108. cialis generic brand

    zanaflex online [url=https://zanaflex.xyz/#]tizanidine online purchase [/url] will zanaflex make hydrocodone stronger how does zanaflex work with percocet

  109. drug cartia

    zanaflex and weed buy zanaflex online with no prescription what muscle relaxer is stronger than zanaflex which is stronger zanaflex or skelaxin

  110. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# best over the counter viagra

  111. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]best over the counter viagra[/url] viagra from india

  112. lasix 40mg generic – allopurinol online oral doxycycline 100mg

  113. Jamisontog

    best place to buy viagra online sildenafil
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# viagra cost
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]sildenafil[/url] mexican viagra

  114. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.com/ where to buy viagra

  115. plaquenil cheap do you need a prescription for hydroxychloroquine

  116. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]viagra for men[/url] where to buy viagra online

  117. cenforce without prescription – cenforce brand domperidone over the counter

  118. Jamisontog

    п»їviagra pills buy viagra online canada
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# buy real viagra online
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]sildenafil 20 mg[/url] cheap viagra online

  119. SildeTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# buy viagra online usa

  120. viagra online generic cheap order viagra from india

  121. combivent discount

    la dapoxetine cost of dapoxetine how to use dapoxetine and sildenafil tablets how long does dapoxetine helpnyou last in bed

  122. kamagra sale

    cialis 40 mg [url=http://australiaviagra.today/#]natural viagra alternatives [/url] how to order viagra online where can i get cialis online

  123. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]sildenafil[/url] mexican viagra

  124. viagra tablet – buy cialis online cheap brand cialis 40mg

  125. Scottfuels

    https://zithromaxforsale.shop/# zithromax 250 mg pill

  126. Stepheneralo

    [url=https://clomidforsale.life/#]order clomid online[/url] can you buy clomid online

  127. RickySpupt

    [url=https://prednisoneforsale.store/#]how to purchase prednisone online[/url] prednisone 5mg over the counter

  128. RaymondOnepe

    zithromax 500 mg lowest price online zithromax 250 mg australia

  129. generic modafinil 100mg – rhinocort sale purchase budesonide pills

  130. Stepheneralo

    https://zithromaxforsale.shop/# zithromax buy online

  131. generic plaquenil 200mg buy hydroxychloroquine canada

  132. ShelbyLeW

    [url=https://zithromaxforsale.shop/#]zithromax 500 mg[/url] zithromax cost australia

  133. cialis 20 mg online

    ventolin recall 2018 ventolin australia when to use ventolin inhaler ventolin how to use

  134. zithromax online australia zithromax capsules australia
    https://doxycyclineforsale.life/# doxycycline 20 mg
    [url=https://zithromaxforsale.shop/#]zithromax z-pak price without insurance[/url] zithromax generic cost

  135. Williamgof

    https://buynolvadex.store/# femara vs tamoxifen

  136. Glenntroup

    lipitor 10mg price in india lipitor

  137. accutane online order – isotretinoin 40mg canada tetracycline price

  138. RickySpupt

    metformin 500mg canada glucophage metformin
    https://buytadalafil.men/# cost of tadalafil in canada
    [url=https://buylipitor.store/#]lipitor rx cost[/url] lipitor australia

  139. RaymondOnepe

    https://buymetformin.best/# can you buy metformin

  140. how to get propecia

    viagra paypal accepted [url=https://viagrafr.online/#]comment avoir du viagra [/url] ordonnance en ligne pour viagra comment crГ©er du viagra

  141. lasix 10 mg daily

    viagra suppliers price of cialis buy cialis online with mastercard hello google how long do you take cialis before sex

  142. cyclobenzaprine tablet – brand inderal propranolol brand

  143. EdwardPluch

    lipitor generic brand lipitor tabs

  144. Anthonyclorn

    https://buymetformin.best/# metformin tab cost in india

  145. RickySpupt

    metformin 143 metformin 10 tablet
    https://buynolvadex.store/# nolvadex estrogen blocker
    [url=https://buymetformin.best/#]metformin buy australia[/url] metformin hydrochloride 500 mg

  146. Williamgof

    cost of lipitor in australia cost of lipitor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.