Why should we keep Torah Law?

Question:
Hello,
 

Thank you for your interesting presentation of the subject but I have an objection.  I was going to say I found an error but that would assume that I am right, and the more humble approach is to not assume I am right but to be open to the possibility that I am wrong.
 

The part where you say what makes God God is not that he is all powerful or the creator but because the instructions for Torah actually work.  
 

It may be good initially to entice people to follow Torah with a reward incentive, that is to say if you follow Torah you will be rewarded with peace, happiness, wealth etc.  But there is a teaching in the Mishneh Torah concerning the 7 laws of Noah which states, that anyone who observes the commandments in order to receive a reward does not have a place in the world to come, rather the commandments must be fulfilled simply because God commanded them.  In this will he merit a place in the world to come.

And these are my own words: and why would someone do what God commands? because God is the creator, and as his creation is right and just to be obedient to him, as is evidenced by the Torah which states that one must honor their parents.  
 

Although these words were directed as bnei Noah, logic would seem to suggest that it is likely they apply to all of God’s creation.
 

peace,

eran

 

Answer:

Regarding why anyone should keep commandments, This is just the Rambam’s opinion (he is very well entitled to it).

In regards to keeping them (7 laws) because G-d gave them (in Hil Melachim) this is only regarding someone who is seeking a share in the next world (something that not even the Torah itself ever claims exists).
I was trying to justify the keeping of any of G-ds commands from a literal understanding of the text and its characters, ie without bringing any later mystical notion of impulse because of some promise of a later metaphysical reward which does not appear in the text anyways.
 
The unchangeable fact is that the Torah offered us commands to keep, why you keep them is really up to you, although I do think that trying to entice people with some future reward when the Torah is silent of such a reward (while still calling it torah) is misleading and dishonest.
 
The only things that we as those who study the commands that appear in Torah can objectively know is that for the most part they (the laws) work in improving not just our personal lives but or surroundings as well.
(which is the only argument we can offer skeptics inquiring about Judaism.
 
That being said I do believe in a reward but I don’t think that the Torah commands me to.
 
R’ Asher Meza

Post navigation

130 Comments
  1. Montetraps

    [url=http://cheapdrugs.store/#]mens erections[/url]

  2. Jeffreylew

    prednisone brand name us prednisone 5mg capsules cost of prednisone 10mg tablets

  3. Jeffreylew

    ivermectin covid 19 ivermectin pour on for goats ivermectin for tapeworms

  4. Jeffreylew

    drugs online homeopathic remedies for ed pharmacy online

  5. Jeffreylew

    prednisone 10mg prices buy prednisone prednisone 50 mg prices

  6. Jeffreylew

    ivermectin horse paste ingredients ivermectin for cats ivermectin for birds

  7. Jeffreylew

    50 mg prednisone tablet generic prednisone prednisone without prescription.net

  8. Jeffreylew

    online drugs ed vacuum pumps medications online

  9. Jeffreylew

    prednisone 60 mg prednisone tablets prednisone 5mg capsules

  10. RogerPrend

    cheap propecia finasteride without doctor propecia pill

  11. RogerPrend

    cheap generic propecia finasteride propecia tablets

  12. RogerPrend

    prescription drugs carprofen without vet prescription non prescription erection pills

  13. RogerPrend

    where can i buy oral ivermectin ivermectin praziquantel for dogs ivermectin lotion price

  14. RogerPrend

    ed meds online without doctor prescription dog antibiotics without vet prescription buy prescription drugs

  15. RogerPrend

    amoxicillin without a doctor’s prescription buy prescription drugs without doctor dog antibiotics without vet prescription

  16. RogerPrend

    non prescription ed pills best over the counter ed pills п»їerectile dysfunction medication

  17. Normangep

    stromectol for sale stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for humans for sale

  18. Normangep

    meds online without doctor prescription canadian pharmacy certified canada pharmacy online reputable canadian mail order pharmacies

  19. Normangep

    canada rx drugs online order prescriptions online without doctor trusted online canadian pharmacy reviews

  20. buy modafinil 100mg for sale provigil 200mg over the counter

  21. provigil over the counter order modafinil 200mg online

  22. Normangep

    buy stromectol online buy stromectol online stromectol for sale

  23. erythromycin benzoyl peroxide topical gel erythromycin and acne

  24. modafinil sale order modafinil 200mg pill

  25. order provigil without prescription order modafinil generic buy provigil 100mg without prescription

  26. JohnnyinOrp

    clomid tablets for sale buy clomid 50mg online clomid for sale

  27. purchase provigil pills modafinil 100mg without prescription

  28. order provigil 200mg online purchase modafinil generic buy provigil 100mg pill

  29. order modafinil brand provigil 200mg

  30. JohnnyinOrp

    stromectol for humans for sale stromectol 3 mg tablets price stromectol for sale

  31. order modafinil 200mg for sale order provigil 200mg generic

  32. cost modafinil buy generic modafinil 200mg

  33. JohnnyinOrp

    clomid for sale clomid clomid for sale canada

  34. cheap provigil buy modafinil 100mg sale modafinil 100mg brand

  35. modafinil 200mg pill order provigil 100mg pills

  36. oral provigil 100mg buy modafinil without prescription

  37. JohnnyinOrp

    stromectol for humans for sale stromectol for sale prescribing stromectol

  38. JohnnyinOrp

    tadalafil best price 20 mg cialis coupon online purchase of tadalafil in india

  39. modafinil over the counter provigil 200mg for sale

  40. JohnnyinOrp

    viagra pills price for viagra viagra pills

  41. buy provigil 200mg for sale provigil 200mg cheap provigil 100mg without prescription

  42. buy modafinil 100mg pill modafinil order online provigil online order

  43. Eddiesuisa

    ivermectin 9 mg stromectol 12 mg tablets injectable ivermectin

  44. antibiotic erythromycin azithromycin and erythromycin

  45. Eddiesuisa

    stromectol tablets for humans stromectol 12 mg tablets stromectol for humans for sale

  46. Eddiesuisa

    stromectol for sale stromectol tablets for humans stromectol 12 mg tablets

  47. MichaelJes

    buy generic 100mg viagra online viagra pills price of viagra

  48. MichaelJes

    viagra from canada pfizer viagra 100mg price over the counter viagra

  49. canadian prescriptions online

    medicin without prescription

  50. cheap prescription drugs

    canadian drug stores

  51. MichaelJes

    where to buy viagra online viagra tablets for men best place to buy viagra online

  52. buy cialis 36 hour buying cialis online in australia can women take cialis

  53. black tab cialis tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription cialis with dapoxetine usa

  54. cialis professional legitimate price of cialis 20 mg cialis daily pricing

  55. cheap. generic cialisis best price for daily cialis tadalafil ( cialis )

  56. 10 mg generic cialis tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription cheapest cialis canada

  57. http://erythromycinn.com/# erythromycin ointment dosage

  58. cialis generic best price buy tadalafil get cialis overnight

  59. erythromycin benzoyl peroxide topical gel erythromycin gastroparesis

  60. siwy4

    pnk9a

    8p9n

  61. RalphEdirl

    best price cialis gen tadalafil 20mg

  62. y27o1

    bnsvz

    [url=http://novrazbb.com/#]3z67[/url]

  63. cost of ivermectin pill ivermectin price comparison

  64. Chesterswogy

    https://stromectolgf.com/# buy ivermectin cream

  65. erythromycin wiki erythromycin allergy

  66. StromTWirm

    [url=https://stromectolgf.com/#]stromectol 3 mg tablets price[/url] stromectol how much it cost

  67. wu54m

    aqyeb

    ovdg

  68. erythromycin eye ointment erythromycin allergy

  69. CameronFeedy

    canadian drugs canadian drug prices

  70. CameronFeedy

    buy prescription drugs from india ed meds online without doctor prescription

  71. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.online/#]canadian drugs[/url] mexican pharmacy without prescription

  72. CameronFeedy

    best online canadian pharmacy buy prescription drugs without doctor

  73. ThomasDog

    [url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.site/#]buy prescription drugs from canada cheap[/url] cvs prescription prices without insurance

  74. where to get hydroxychloroquine otc https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/

  75. buy ventolin

    kamagra forum [url=https://kamagraaustralia.quest/#]were to buy kamagra [/url] tabletki na potencjД™ bez recepty kamagra how to take kamagra tablets

  76. kamagra buy

    acheter kamagra oral kamagra uk paypal comment prendre kamagra oral jelly how quickly does kamagra work

  77. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra[/url] cost of viagra

  78. Jamisontog

    buy viagra online canada viagra shop
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# best over the counter viagra
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]buying viagra online[/url] viagra over the counter

  79. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.online/# how much is viagra

  80. sildenafil 20 mg tablet walgreens

    sildenafil citrate tablets

  81. plaquenil package insert buying hydroxychloroquine online

  82. BrandonLaf

    100mg viagra viagra shop

  83. cartia 100 mg

    neurontin used for [url=https://neurontin.site/#]neurontin 400 mg cost [/url] ingredients of neurontin 600 mg how much is gabapentin without insurance

  84. sildenafil citrate online

    women viagra

  85. cost of priligy

    online cialis cialis price comparison australia women’s viagra does it work how to get a prescription for cialis online

  86. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]buy viagra online usa[/url] where to buy viagra

  87. us pharmacy no prior prescription

    us pharmacy no prior prescription

  88. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# where can i buy viagra over the counter

  89. Jamisontog

    cheap viagra online viagra for men
    https://sildenafilmg.online/# order viagra online
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra[/url] viagra 100mg price

  90. BrandonLaf

    best over the counter viagra viagra

  91. MichaelTeelm

    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online

  92. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]viagra 100mg price[/url] buy real viagra online

  93. BrandonLaf

    viagra 100mg price viagra coupons 75% off

  94. Jamisontog

    viagra amazon order viagra online
    https://sildenafilmg.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
    [url=https://sildenafilmg.com/#]viagra pills[/url] viagra 100mg price

  95. sildenafil viagra

    dapoxetine studies dapoxetine canada tadalafil dapoxetine brands in india how much does priligy cost

  96. BrandonLaf

    best over the counter viagra sildenafil

  97. MichaelFem

    [url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]online doctor prescription for viagra[/url] generic viagra walmart

  98. cialis manufacturer

    priligy review blogs [url=http://priligy.site/#]priligy usa sale [/url] comprar priligy original en usa how to get a prescription of dapoxetine

  99. https://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ hydroxychloroquine online sale

  100. RaymondOnepe

    where can i buy doxycycline order doxycycline no prescription

  101. The information you have on this blog is so good that I wouldn’t mind paying to be able to access it. But could you please do something about the spam here. It prevents me from asking questions about the subject. Great resource, anyway. Shouldn’t be complaining I guess. Lol

  102. RickySpupt

    [url=https://prednisoneforsale.store/#]prednisone otc uk[/url] prednisone in mexico

  103. Robertzet

    generic doxycycline doxycycline 200

  104. Georgeram

    amoxicillin 875 mg tablet how much is amoxicillin prescription

  105. levitra 10 mg cost

    dapoxetine что это dapoxetine 30mg tab tadalafil 20 mg with dapoxetine 30 mg how to get priligy in the us

  106. where to get zithromax over the counter generic zithromax medicine
    https://doxycyclineforsale.life/# doxycycline antibiotics
    [url=https://amoxilforsale.best/#]amoxicillin cephalexin[/url] can i purchase amoxicillin online

  107. ShelbyLeW

    [url=https://prednisoneforsale.store/#]prednisone 0.5 mg[/url] buy prednisone 10mg

  108. Georgeram

    clomid 50 mg tablet price best otc clomid

  109. zanaflex 48 mg

    azithromycin for gonorrhea [url=https://zithromax.guru/#]zithromax capsules 500mg [/url] can you drink alcohol on zithromax how does azithromycin work for chlamydia

  110. RaymondOnepe

    https://buylipitor.store/# lipitor tablets

  111. PhilipGow

    metformin purchase uk metformin where to buy
    https://buymetformin.best/# metformin er 500
    [url=https://buylipitor.store/#]lipitor 40 mg cost[/url] lipitor

  112. RickySpupt

    lasix 40mg furosemide 100 mg
    https://buymetformin.best/# metformin glucophage
    [url=https://buymetformin.best/#]india pharmacy metformin 500 mg[/url] online no prescription metformin

  113. order cenforce sale

    latisse treatment [url=https://bimatoprost.xyz/#]how long for latisse to work [/url] does latisse darken eye color why can’t you put latisse on bottom lashes

  114. cialis gГ©nГ©rique prix

    reddit cenforce cenforce online order cenforce soft 100 usa cenforce review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.